Many would argue that astrobiology research is interdisciplinary. Is it? And what does 'interdisciplinary' actually mean? What about the education side of it? Is interdisciplinary education a real thing or bogus? Let's challenge some of the things that we take for granted regarding interdisciplinarity. I am hoping to have a discussion on interdisciplinarity in astrobiology research and education using Rosenfield's taxonomy. I do not know the answers to the questions below but I am sure we will have a great time discussing them on S.A.G.A.N. Salon.


-Where does the current astrobiology research operate: multi-, inter-, or transdisciplinary?
-Where it should be?
-How can we train the next generation of researchers who want to conduct interdisciplinary research?
-Does interdisciplinary Ph.D. programs have a value?
-What are the barriers to and facilitators of interdisciplinary research?

Rosenfield's taxonomy (1992):
Unidisciplinarity: Researcher(s) are from a single discipline, may work together.
Multidisciplinarity: Researchers are from different disciplines and they work independently or sequentially. Each has own disciplinary perspective.
Interdisciplinarity: Researchers are from different disciplines and they work jointly. Each stays anchored in own field but results demonstrate some integration of diverse disciplines.
Transdisciplinarity: Researchers are from different disciplines and they work jointly to create a shared conceptual framework. This moves beyond discipline-specific theories, concepts, and approaches.

Views: 72

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

It seems that Rosenfield's taxonomy is the ideal "roadmap" for astrobiology research. Transdisciplinarity should be the educational goal, but I don't think the community is there yet. Interdisciplinarity perhaps best characterizes the current state of astrobiology research. Not to be biased, but I think the UW model really pushes its students from multi- to trans-.

I'm looking forward to the discussion!

I do not think it will happen in our lifetime -transdisciplinarity as the educational goal. However, I hope that we can come up with a model that can broaden students' and researchers' intellectual peripheral vision -that is the understanding and knowledge of how other disciplines could be helpful to one's research (and vice versa). For instance, I paleobiologist told me, "if I don’t know anything about microbiology, then I'm not in a position to ask what a new phylogeny might do for my understanding of fossils." And I guess UW model does this.

Anyway, I am very excited about the discussion.

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Blog Posts

Using tried and tested methods of constructing habitats from ethnobotanical and ethnozoological useful species for self sustainability on Mars

Posted by Andrew Planet on June 26, 2020 at 8:00am 0 Comments

To maximize crop yields on Mars it would be advantageous to do away with annuals and biannuals by engineering the latter into perennials as standard. Not only would that entail far less work to grow produce as the act of replanting is made obsolete, but per given cultivated area perennials bring forth more food and materials with less demand from the soil than the equivalent of annuals.

Imagine a superfood annual such as lentils engineered into a lentil tree for which there already…

Continue

Free astrobiology webinars for kids, summer 2020

Posted by Julia Brodsky on June 13, 2020 at 12:28pm 0 Comments

This summer, Art of Inquiry hosts free space exploration and astrobiology webinars for middle-school students and their families all over the world.



Here is a list of what was covered so far, as well as an updated schedule of webinars:

The search for life in the Universe, Dr. Alex Tsapin, JPL (retired)

The history of SETI, SETIQuest editor, Larry…

Continue

Radiolysis-powered life

Posted by Andrew Planet on June 11, 2020 at 9:56pm 7 Comments

This paper greatly extends the possibility of what a Goldilocks zone can be.  Its no longer the Goldilocks zone as a single expanse, its the Goldilocks zones for a particular area

https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/pdf/10.1098/rsif.2016.0459

¿Are the Venusian sulphuric acid clouds the by product of long dead anoxogenic photosynthetic organisms?

Posted by Andrew Planet on May 4, 2020 at 2:51pm 2 Comments

I just read the piece at the link below entitled "Study: Life might survive, and thrive, in a hydrogen world."

I'd been thinking on similar lines recently, on different atmospheres with early life, but I was considering anoxogenic bacteria whose byproduct is sulfur instead of molecular oxygen. ¿Had life evolved on Venus could its sulfuric clouds be the signature byproduct of such life with no branches ever evolving to produce the equivalent of Earth's Great…

Continue

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

Forum

Ask your questions here!

Started by Gina Riggio in SAGANet Discussions. Last reply by Chirag Parmar on Sunday. 125 Replies

If you are trying to ask a question live during Ask an Astrobiologist, please do so in the main chatroom at the bottom of the screen! You can also ask on twitter…Continue

Inhabitation on mars, with plants or without?

Started by Chirag Parmar in The Cutting-Edge of Astrobiology on Sunday. 0 Replies

hello there, Chirag Parmar this side!i am a biotechnology student and currently on research of plants on other planets! The main issue is the gravity of the planet! If we take mars as an example, the…Continue

Tags: #plantsonplanets, #mars, #plants

Have we been looking in the wrong time-frame? Requesting feedback on a recent paper.

Started by Christopher J Reiss in The Cutting-Edge of Astrobiology. Last reply by Greg Bowen Jun 30. 5 Replies

Let me first say Hi to everyone as a new member here!   I hope you are all safe, sound, and not too stir-crazy during this Pandemic.I recently stumbled upon a notion for SETI which seems so simple I…Continue

Interactive Online Astrobiology for 10-12 yr olds

Started by Julia Brodsky in Education and Public Outreach Mar 9. 0 Replies

If your 10-12 yr old child is interested in space science, I would like to invite them to our courses. I am a former science teacher,  mom of three, and a former NASA astronaut instructor. I also…Continue

Tags: school, education, middle, astrobiology, STEM

© 2020   Blue Marble Space, a non-profit organization committed to science and science outreach.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service