Considering this week’s discussion on the role of bias and dogma within science, I figured it would be best for me to write my post on the importance of philosophy and hypotheticals in science, especially in a field such as origin of life. This is a subject matter I somewhat understand and hopefully something the rest of might find a tad interesting.

The most prominent thinker is this subject matter, as far as I am concerned, would be Thomas Kuhn. Kuhn was a physicist and philosopher in the mid-twentieth century whose philosophy was chiefly concerned progress of science and how we reshape our thoughts. He argued that scientific thought does not progress gradually but rather through large “paradigm shifts”. This may seem obvious now, reflecting upon historical examples such as the idea of the cell and heliocentric solar system certainly lend credence to this being the case, but Kuhn was among the first to solidify this phenomenon into a theory. In his book The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, he wrote about the three stages that science goes through in order to achieve an accepted paradigm. First there is “Prescience” in which scientists search to find the paradigm under which their work will be conducted. This is where I feel the origin of life research currently is, but I will discuss that later. Next comes what he called “normal science”, in which research is done in order to expand the paradigm and research that does not conform with it is rejected as error by the scientist and not a problem with the paradigm. Eventually, as more and more research contradicts the current paradigm, a new paradigm is defined in what is called “revolutionary science”. Kuhn argued that once a paradigm had been agreed upon "the profession will have solved problems that its members could scarcely have imagined and would never have undertaken without commitment to the paradigm" (24).

These concepts have been vital in social science fields, where the presence paradigms can often seem less apparent than in normal science due to their nature being rooted in our humanity. I feel as though the origin of life field should be evaluated by Kuhn’s terms as it too can be biased by our humanity. Frequently when considering the origin of life it can become easy to pigeonhole one’s thinking into narrow corridors by only considering life as we know it. It is hard to imagine evaluating life that is not like the life we see every day, but considering concepts like the shadow biosphere and the vast size of the universe, it is very likely that there is life that goes beyond our simple comprehension of life. I believe it is vital for us first to have an explicitly defined paradigm of what is life before we ask how is life. This ties into another concept Kuhn wrote on, the role of dogma within scientific research. Kuhn argued that dogma could create issues in nearly every step of the scientific process, even when it it came to experimental design as researchers will create tools which search to prove their hypothesis, but this can narrow the scope of information to be found. Our lack of knowledge on all of what life can be could prevent us from understanding the ancient life that existed when life first came about. A true paradigm on what is life is a monumental task and one which would require extensive amounts of time and research to figure out, but is something which appears essential to understanding the origin of life question.


Views: 166


You need to be a member of SAGANet to add comments!

Join SAGANet


  • Add Photos
  • View All

Blog Posts

The 5th Mexican School of Astrobiology

Posted by Tardigrelda on June 24, 2019 at 1:00pm 0 Comments

I am really glad to invite everyone to the next Mexican School of Astrobiology (aka EMA) which is this August.

¡Anímate a participar en la 5ta Escuela Mexicana de…


A consortium of representatives of European Research Organisations has taken the initiative to create a virtual institute named the “European Astrobiology Institute” (EAI) with the ambition of enabli…

Posted by Wolf D. Geppert on February 24, 2019 at 1:33am 0 Comments

A consortium of representatives of European Research Organisations has taken the initiative to create a virtual institute named the “European Astrobiology Institute” (EAI) with the ambition of enabling Europe to emerge as a key player in Astrobiology and to…


AbSciCon session on life in high salt habitats

Posted by Jeff Bowman on December 14, 2018 at 8:12am 0 Comments

Abstract submissions are open for AbSciCon 2019!  You can check out the full selection of sessions here, however, I'd like to draw your attention toward the session Salty Goodness: Understanding life, biosignature…


vemala Network

Posted by Apit Supriatna on October 7, 2018 at 1:07am 0 Comments merupakan situs yang membahas seputar gaya hidup, dengan berbagai macam informasi kesehatan, olahraga, Fitness, review, kecantikan, relationship,Lifestile, Tips kehamilan,Fashion dan lain sebagainya.


  • Add Videos
  • View All


Ask your questions here!

Started by Gina Riggio in SAGANet Discussions. Last reply by Lauren Seyler on Monday. 57 Replies

If you are trying to ask a question live during Ask an Astrobiologist, please do so in the main chatroom at the bottom of the screen! You can also ask on twitter…Continue

Internship in Astrobiology

Started by Eva Zanditenas in Jobs / Post-docs / Other opportunities Oct 9. 0 Replies

Hi, My name is Eva Zanditenas, I am in my final year of biotechnology (in Paris) and I looking for an internship of six months to conclude my studies.   I am passionate about astrobiology, and it is…Continue

Tags: internship

European Astrobilogy Institute now on Twitter !

Started by Wolf D. Geppert in SAGANet Community Sep 24. 0 Replies

ear All,The European Astrobiology Institute is now on Twitter : @EAIastrobiologyIf you are interested: Follow us!If you like a tweet: Like us!If you find a tweet interesting: Retweet!If you want us…Continue

Spiritual connection

Started by MOHIT Kakkar in The Cutting-Edge of Astrobiology Jun 15. 0 Replies

Hi pls answer my spiritual questions.Continue

© 2019   Blue Marble Space, a non-profit organization committed to science and science outreach.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service